Inside The Super Bowl Ads

Last Sunday was Super Sunday, normally a great day for advertisers to showcase their great ads. However, the ads were sub-par…again. Especially compared to the game, which was great.

But this post isn’t about the game. It’s about how the advertisers fared during the Super Bowl. Mullen and Radian6 collected and analyzed close to 100,000 tweets tagged #brandbowl to determine how brands and their Super Bowl ads were perceived on Twitter. The ranking of ads was based on a combination of volume (number of tweets) and sentiment (positive or negative). You can check out the results on the #brandbowl website.

Doritos won because of sheer volume and they did have a lot of ads! Numbers 2 and 3, Google and Focus on the Family, didn’t have as many ads so their ranking is impressive. Google’s ad was very clever and was one of favorites of the evening. The Focus on the Family one was amusing but mostly to Americans because of the involvement of former college football superstar Tim Tebow.

[Read more...]

Quid Pro Quo

This post is part rant, part case study. Lately, I’ve been extremely annoyed by two campaigns on Twitter.

The first campaign was by Squarespace. They asked people to use the hash tag #squarespace in their tweets. People could do this randomly and were encouraged to do it as often as possible. Squarespace would select a lucky winner every day and give that person a gift voucher for the Apple Store.

The second campaign was by Moonfruit. It was a similar campaign where, during a week, people could enter a competition to win one Apple MacBook Pro each day. People were automatically entered into the competition if they used the hash tag #moonfruit in their tweets and again, people were stimulated to do it as often as possible.

These brands have succeeded in getting their brand names into the social media space, but it’s been done in a dubious way. Moreover, they haven’t performed any true form of consumer engagement, which just means that they let people flood Twitter with their brand name without any proper context.

Don’t use social media as a cheap promotional tool. Use social media to genuine build relationships.